The Evangelicals: The Struggle to Shape America

Book Review: The Evangelicals: The Struggle to Shape America
By Frances FitzGerald

Estimated Rating: ★★★★☆ (4.16 out of 5 stars)

(Note: Looking back from our current date in June 2026, almost a decade after its 2017 release, this heavily awarded text remains a foundational pillar for understanding the intersection of religion and politics in the United States.)

Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts, critiques, and analyses presented below are entirely my own.

Publication and Context

Title: The Evangelicals: The Struggle to Shape America
Author: Frances FitzGerald
First Published: April 4, 2017 (Simon & Schuster)
Page Count: 753 pages
Format: Kindle Edition (ASIN: B01HMXV362 / ISBN: 9781439143155)
Genres: History / Nonfiction / Religion / Politics / American History
Awards: Winner of the 2017 National Book Critics Circle Award, National Book Award Finalist (2017), Time Magazine Top 10 Nonfiction Book of the Year

Contextual Backdrop:
Authored by Pulitzer Prize-winning historian Frances FitzGerald, The Evangelicals arrived at a critical juncture in American history—the immediate aftermath of the 2016 presidential election. As political analysts and the public scrambled to understand the voting blocs that shaped modern America, FitzGerald provided a meticulously researched, sweeping historical lens. In 2026, the book serves as vital prologue to the immense political and cultural shifts of the last decade.

Purpose and Themes of the Work

The book’s primary purpose is to trace the complex, dramatic evolution of the Evangelical movement in the United States from its Puritan roots to its status as a formidable political machine. FitzGerald seeks to demystify a group often viewed monolithically by outsiders, exploring themes of populism, schism, cultural assimilation, and the eventual, deep-seated marriage between conservative theology and the Republican Party.

Summary of the Work

Over the course of 753 pages, FitzGerald chronicles the lifecycle of American evangelicalism. She begins with the 18th and 19th-century Great Awakenings, illustrating how the movement started as a populist rebellion against established, elite churches.

The narrative carefully tracks the subsequent ideological and regional fractures: the Civil War-era split between North and South, and the early 20th-century divide between modernists and fundamentalists. Post-World War II, the book highlights Billy Graham’s monumental efforts to unite Protestants under a massive, apolitical tent. However, the cultural revolutions and civil rights movements of the 1960s fractured this unity once more.

The latter half of the book details the rise of the Christian Right in the 1980s, spearheaded by figures like Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson. By weaponizing issues like abortion and gay rights, they successfully tethered Southern and conservative evangelicals to the Republican Party. FitzGerald concludes her timeline around the 2016 election, noting the emergence of a younger, more diverse generation of evangelicals focused on a broader agenda (climate change, immigration) and warning that the movement must embrace ethnic minorities to survive its demographic decline.

Analysis and Evaluation

Format, Pacing, and Structure

At over 700 pages, this is an “epic history” in the truest sense. The structure is chronological, building a steady, heavily footnoted foundation before accelerating into the highly charged political history of the late 20th and early 21st centuries. While the pacing is inherently academic, FitzGerald’s prose is accessible and narrative-driven, keeping the dense historical data engaging.

Subjects and Voices

FitzGerald’s voice is remarkably fair-minded and objective. In a subject area rife with partisan polemics, she maintains the disciplined distance of a master historian. She does not mock, nor does she proselytize; she simply observes, records, and contextualizes. Her ability to synthesize complex theological debates into understandable political motivations is a standout achievement.

Strengths and Limitations

Strengths: The sheer scope and depth of research are unparalleled. It is the definitive single-volume history of white American evangelicalism. FitzGerald’s neutral tone allows readers of all political and religious persuasions to engage with the text defensively.
Limitations: From a 2026 reading perspective, the book’s hard stop at the 2016 election feels like a cliffhanger. Readers looking for analysis of the movement’s trajectory during the Trump presidency, the overturning of Roe v. Wade, and the rise of explicit Christian Nationalism will need to look to subsequent authors. Additionally, its length and density require a significant time commitment.

Suitability and Audience Guidance

Content Considerations: Heavy on political and theological history. Discusses the history of racism, segregation, and culture-war topics (abortion, LGBTQ+ rights) within the context of religious doctrine and political strategy.
Target Audience: Highly recommended for history buffs, sociologists, political junkies, religious scholars, and anyone seeking a rigorous, unbiased understanding of how American religion and politics became so deeply intertwined.

Conclusion and Verdict

The Evangelicals: The Struggle to Shape America is a monumental achievement in historical nonfiction. Frances FitzGerald has crafted a lucid, comprehensive, and essential guide to the religious currents that have continually reshaped the American landscape. While history has continued to march forward since its publication, this book remains the indispensable foundation for understanding the modern American political divide.

Search This Blog

Prairie Fox Reads